SOME
INDUSTRIAL INFLUENCES ON THE
EVOLUTION
OF LANDSCAPE IN SNOWDONIA
© 2002/2007 N. R. Walley
TABLE
OF CONTENTS
19TH and
20TH Century Impact on Snowdonia
The
People in
Mining and Quarrying – Housing
The
People in
Mining and Quarrying – Industrial Relations
Slate
– Some
General Considerations
The
Four Great
Slate Deposits of Snowdonia
The
Collapse of
the Slate Market
Penmaenmawr
&
Graiglwyd Granite
The Ffestiniog Railway and its
People
The
Ffestiniog Railway
and its People
George England and
Robert Fairlie
The
Great
Ffestiniog Locomotive Trials – 1870
Sir Henry Whately
Tyler, 1827-1908.
Welsh Highland
Railway (Light Railway) Company
The Last Days of the
Old Order
The Bristol Meeting
and the Ffestiniog Revival
The Volunteers and
the Local Groups
The Deviation and the
Deviationists
Rheilffordd
Eryri
– The Welsh Highland Railway
by the same Author:
ROYAL
RE-OPENING FOR THE WELSH HIGHLAND RAILWAY
CHANGE
& DEVELOPMENT IN NORTH WALES 1750–1950
NORTH
STAFFORDSHIRE RAILWAY PASSENGER SERVICES
This
paper was inspired by the industrial and railway aspects of a
ten-week course on the “Evolution of Landscape in Snowdonia” organised
by
University of Wales Bangor at the Community Centre, Craig y Don,
Llandudno and
given early in 2002 by Gwilym T. Jones of the University of Wales,
Bangor. The
paper draws heavily on the writer’s longstanding interest in the narrow
gauge
railways of
Noel
Walley,
Llandudno,
2002
Edited
by the author for reproduction on this website, various
dates. Photographs added December 2007, Noel Walley.
For
the purposes of this study, the delimiters of Snowdonia were
set as follows:
1. To the North:
The
Menai Straits
2. To the East:
The
3. To the West:
The Caernarfon –
4. To the South: The
Vale of Ffestiniog
Based
on the above definition, Snowdonia can be seen to include
the Penmaenmawr granite quarries, the
The
The
fourteen
Thomas
Firbank and two friends established a new record in 1938 of
eight hours twenty minutes (down from 10½ hours) by following a novel
and
carefully planned route starting at the summit of
Firbank’s
wife Esmé, in a separate party with Thomas, their
shepherd, starting earlier on the same day and by the same route,
established a
new woman’s record of nine hours 25 minutes, which was over one hour
faster
than the previous best by a man. Her contribution to the route planning
had
also been significant.[1]
Esmé
and her second husband Peter
Kirby later
founded the Snowdonia National Park Society,
exercising considerable influence in the conservation lobby. She died
in 1999.
The
fourteen peaks were climbed in the following order:
|
Name |
|
|
|
height |
|
|
|
|
|
feet |
|
Y Wyddfa ( |
|
|
|
3,560 |
|
Crib y ddysgyl |
|
|
|
3,493 |
|
Crib Goch |
|
|
|
3,023 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Elidyr Fawr |
|
|
|
3,029 |
|
Y Garn |
|
|
|
3,104 |
|
Glyder Fawr |
|
|
|
3,279 |
|
Glyder Fach |
|
|
|
3,262 |
|
Tryfan |
|
|
|
3,010 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Pen yr Oleu
Wen |
|
|
|
3,210 |
|
Carnedd Dafydd |
|
|
|
3,426 |
|
Yr Elen |
|
|
|
3,151 |
|
Carnedd
Llewelyn |
|
|
|
3,484 |
|
Foel Grach |
|
|
|
3,195 |
|
Foel Fras |
|
|
|
3,091 |
The
impact of railways on the Snowdonian landscape, apart from the Snowdon
Mountain
Railway and those lines associated with quarrying, has been largely
peripheral.
The main railway lines date from the second half of the nineteenth
century and
mainly follow the boundaries used for this study. Firstly, the
L&NWR line
from Llandudno Junction to
Mining
and quarrying down the centuries in Snowdonia had been concerned with
the
search for and extraction of non-ferrus metallic ores wherever they
could be
found. These workings had generally been abandoned by the 19th
century, but the evidence of such is there for all to see, leaving a
permanent
impact on the slopes of
At first slow to establish,
by 1801, slate was being worked in each of the four main slate areas of
Snowdonia. The impact of slate working on the landscape of Snowdonia
came late but
by the start of the nineteenth century the presence of the slate
quarries was
noticeable and the environmental impact of this quickly growing
industry soon
became enormous. Granite quarrying came to Snowdonia even later. More extensive than any other industrial
activity in Snowdonia, the impact of quarrying is clear for all to see.
Once it
became established as a major industry, slate was to dominate in one
form or
another the Snowdonian labour market for over 150 years. This resulted
in the
establishment of new towns and villages, which in themselves were a
factor in
the evolution of the landscape. A good transport system was vital to
the
success of the quarries and most quarries were linked by narrow gauge
railways
and tramways to nearby ports and/or to standard gauge wharves for
distribution
throughout the country. This paper concentrates on the transport
aspects of the
slate industry, which significantly reduced handling costs and enabled
quarrying to develop at a far faster rate than otherwise would have
happened.
The establishment of the
quarries led to the establishment of service industries especially iron
foundries such as the Britannia foundry by the Cob at Porthmadog (now
demolished and replaced by the local Tax Office) and the firm of De
Winton at
Caernarfon (this historic listed foundry in St. Helen’s Road survives
as a
plumber’s showroom). Both these companies served the ship building
industry as
well as quarrying, mining and railways. De Winton & Co. also built
a small
steam engine for quarry use with a distinctive vertical boiler adapted
from
that firm’s marine experience. These engines were hand built to order
and it is
believed no two were identical although all were similar. Iron beams
cast by De
Winton & Co. survive in the roof of the former railway tunnel, now
a little
used road tunnel, under the centre of Caernarfon.
In
the early 19th century, most quarrymen were also
farm labourers or smallholders and quarrying for some was only a part
time
occupation. But many men travelled considerable distances on foot to
work,
leaving home very early on Monday and stayed all week at the quarries
living in
barracks and then walking home on Saturday afternoon. Later, trains and
even
later, buses enabled them to stay at home and travel daily to work.
Those who
travelled by train would pass the time engaged in conversation or story
telling
or on the Ffestiniog Railway at least (where the later quarrymen’s
carriages
held 14 men) formed themselves into small choirs. However, many men
tired of
hours of travelling or lonely barracks and built for themselves
cottages or had
built for them terraced cottages near the quarries – in this way new
villages
and towns like
Important
in any industry are the relationships existing between master and
servant,
within the place of work, and between different groups of men. This is
as true
in the slate industry as anywhere. At
Two
simple lists of qualities and uses are sufficient to show why, given
cheap
transport, and an improved quality of life – in the kingdom as well as
in the
locality, the slate industry blossomed and flourished within two
decades.
Ultimately the high waste factor and the high levels of manual skill
and effort
needed to produce roofing slates, with no possibility of the
mechanisation of
the core skills, led to the quick demise of slate once mass production
methods
were introduced to the making of ceramic tiles.
Among
its many qualities are the following:
1.
Slate
is impervious to water
2.
Slate
is chemically inert and impervious to chemical action
3.
Slate
possesses coldness
4.
Slate
is fire proof
5.
Slate
has almost no electrical conductivity
6.
Slate
surfaces are flat and can be polished
7.
Slate
can be carved and even turned on a lathe.
8.
Slate
possesses attractive natural colour-fast colours.
Among
its many recorded uses are the following:
9.
Roofing
slates and walling material
10.
Roman
Aqueducts at Segontium
11.
Tanks for
liquids, be it
water or beer or chemicals
12.
Laboratory
bench tops
13.
Blackboards
and writing
tablets.
14.
Dairy and
bakery work
surfaces
15.
Billiard
table beds and
tombstones
16.
Electrical
Control Panels.
Most
of the extensive deposits of roofing slate in
The
Penrhyn ‘blue’ copper-rich mudstone slate is the characteristic output
of the
Bethesda Quarry. The
The
Penrhyn line did not operate a public passenger service. It did,
however,
possess a single coach, known as the ‘Penrhyn Coach’, for the use of
Lord
Penrhyn and his guests. It had been built by the quarry’s own staff. It
is said
that a fitter and a carpenter were sent to
For
many years, prior to his retirement in the 1950’s, the quarry had a
remarkable
chief engineer J. H. Battersby who controlled the maintenance and
operation of
the 27 engines as well as all other machinery and equipment of the
quarry and
who was held in such high regard that, it is said, no independent
boiler
insurance tests were held, his certification being sufficient.[3]
The line to Port Penrhyn finally closed on
The
town of
Early
in the 1960’s a major engineering company with no previous experience
in slate
invested more than a million pounds in total modernisation and made a
successful transformation of an ailing business. Today, Alfred McAlpine
Ltd is
the major producer in North Wales and offers Welsh slate for sale in
three
finishes ‘flamed’, ‘riven’ and ‘fine-rubbed’ each of the following
colours
‘Heather Blue’, ‘Heather Red’ and ‘Heather Grey’ all from the Penrhyn
Quarry
plus ‘Blue-Grey’ from Ffestiniog and ‘Dark Blue-Grey’ from Cwt y Bugail
(Ffestiniog). Alfred McAlpine Ltd also own The Hilltop Quarries in the
On
the southwestern side of Elidir Fawr in the vale of Llanberis is the
enormous
Dinorwic Quarry formerly owned by the Assheton Smiths. When the quarry
(effectively two quarries side-by-side) finally closed in 1969, there
were 22
named galleries (ponciau) or level shelves on each side, although the
layout is
not nearly so symmetrical as the official charts and diagrams suggest
(On a
photograph there appear to be at least 27 levels). The width of the
galleries
varies from about twelve feet to a hundred feet or more. The two sides
Garret
Side and Braich Side each had their own inclines and lifts by which to
lower
the newly quarried slate to the dressing sheds below. There were nine
permanent
inclines on Braich side and ten on Garret side. Bottom level was at
about 350
ft above sea level with the two highest levels at over 2,100 feet. Thus
the
quarry visibly stands one third of a mile high, over half a mile deep,
and
almost a mile in length, dominating the valley and with extensive waste
tips on
both sides. It is a natural skyscraper factory – yet every square-inch
a
man-made construction – the tallest factory in the world!
Across
the valley, the Snowdon Mountain Railway, in its publicity flier for
2001,
claims that its Halfway Station “stands at 1,641 ft (500 metres) the
height of
the world’s tallest building – The Petronas Tower in
In
its hey-day the Quarry owned 25 steam engines operating on the 1ft 10¾
ins.
quarry tramways. These engines often spent many years working always on
the
same level, since, owing to their weight, it was necessary to dismantle
engines
before they could be moved up and down the inclines. In order to
maintain these
locomotives, well-equipped engine sheds were provided on most levels.
One
engine, Bernstein, built new in 1898 spent 24 years shunting at
Port
Dinorwic then ten years at
Slate
slab wagons called ‘car cyrn’, were specially designed for lowering
down
inclines (or hauling up laden with slabs), and conveyed the rough slate
slabs
to the cutting sheds – these sheds were built at convenient locations
on the
galleries. Owing to the very large amount of waste, it made no sense to
take
undressed slate down to Gilfach Ddu and then have to bring the waste
back up
for dumping. The quarry offices, the
hospital and the extensive workshops for the maintenance of wagons,
engines and
equipment were located on ‘ground level’ in an impressive building at
Gilfach
Ddu where the slate industry museum is now housed. This fine building
is said
to be in the style of an Anglo-Indian fort.
Dressed
roofing slates were taken from Gilfach Ddu to Port Dinorwic (Felinheli)
by
narrow gauge railway. The first line, involving the use of inclines,
was built
in 1824 and was of 1ft 10¾ ins. gauge. It was worked by horses. In
1843, in
order to avoid the use of inclines, a new route was established, still
horse
worked, This new line was built using the quarries own labour but with
James
Spooner of Portmadoc as Consultant. By
1849,
traffic was exceeding the capacity of a horse tramway and steam
locomotives,
still in their infancy, were introduced. These were built to a track
gauge of
exactly 4ft (i.e. 8½ inches narrower than the standard gauge). The
first two
engines, built by A. Horlock of South London, a lesser known builder,
and named
Fire Queen and Jenny Lind, they operated the
trains to
Port Dinorwic until 1886 when the first of three Hunslet 0-6-0 tank
engines
arrived.[5] These were named Dinorwic, Amalthaea and
Velinheli. On withdrawal from service, Fire Queen, was
deliberately
walled up by the senior management (hidden – but with occasional
cleaning and
greasing), unusual preservation in the 19th century. It is
now
preserved at
The
Quarry Company had its head office at the port and also owned the ships
sailing
out of Port Dinorwic. One of their ships was said to have been the
first vessel
to sail into
Major
rock falls in the 1950’s & 60’s had seriously hindered quarry
operations
and a quarry at Marchlyn two miles north of Dinorwic was reopened using
modern
methods and diesel trucks. The trains were scrapped and modern methods
were
extended to the Dinorwic quarry. But it was all too late. Capital
expenditure
had been very heavy and production was not recouping the costs. On
Unlike
Bethesda, where there is almost complete separation of quarry and town
on
opposite sides of the valley, and yet paradoxically it would seem that
the
Bethesda quarrymen travelled shorter distances to work than elsewhere,
Dinorwic
has, in addition to the main quarries many smaller long disused
quarries
scattered over a wide area. Nor does Dinorwic have one significant town
to
match the size of
The
Dinorwic Slate Quarries Railway was late with the provision of a
workmen’s
train, but the workers had their own sturdy private enterprise,
manually
propelled, four wheeled, totally open, rail-cars called ‘Velocipedes’
or ‘Ceir
Gwyllt’ and there were two types of ‘wild car’, the hand operated ‘Ceir
Troi’
and the treadle operated ‘Ceir Cicio’. The Velocipedes were jointly
owned by
groups of workers and theoretically carried 16 men, although a few
extra often
managed to hang on. Speeds of up to 40 mph have been claimed. There
were
eventually 52 of these machines and one of each type is now preserved
in
The
workmen’s train of 23 carriages (including one spare) first ran in 1895
(46
years after the railway opened). The carriages are believed to have
been
obtained second hand from the Taff Vale Railway and were regauged at
In
its prime, all aspects of the railway and tramways were maintained in
first-rate condition. The main line track, for example, was examined
every
morning by three trackmen who each walked one third of the line before
the
morning workmen’s train. Following the closure of the railway and the
quarry,
the level four foot trackbed of the railway from Gilfach Ddu, along the
side of
Llyn Padarn to Penllyn was re-laid to 1ft 10¾ ins gauge and reopened by
Rheilffordd Llyn Llanberis as a tourist railway using three of the
small quarry
locomotives.
Across
the valley on the southwest side of Llyn Padarn at Llanberis were a
separate
group of ten much smaller, independently operated slate quarries. These
operated mostly on the lands of the Ruthin Charity Trust and the
earliest was
first worked c1700 and continued in operation until 1930, its neighbour
was the
last to close in 1931. They had formerly sent their output to
Caernarfon by
road (horse drawn carts) until the building of the L.N.W.R. Llanberis
branch
line in 1869, when transport costs were halved.[8]
Slate
quarrying in the Nantlle region was in progress before 1750. The area
has many
relatively small quarries that were eventually served by several
different
railway systems. The Nantlle Tramway was designed and built by Robert
Stephenson (brother of George) originally as a plateway that at a late
stage in
construction became a tramway to a nominal 3ft 6ins gauge with double
flanged
wheels loose on axles. The line opened for traffic from the quayside at
Caernarfon to Talysarn in 1828.[9] It originally served the Talysarn,
Cilgwyn, Dorothea, and Cloddfarlon quarries and later the Penyorsedd
quarry. In
1867 the Nantlle Tramway was amalgamated with the Caernarvonshire
Railway and
was for the greater part converted to standard gauge. The original
feeder lines
from Talysarn to the quarries remained as horse drawn 3ft 6ins gauge
tramways
and subsequently became part of the LNWR, LMS and eventually
The
inclination of the slate strata in the Nantlle district mostly required
the
excavation of deep vertical pits of slate. These filled with water and
thus
required pumping. At the Dorothea Quarry is a large and very deep pit
that has
at its bottom a very deep freshwater lake. There are characteristics in
respect
of this location and lake that make it particularly suitable and
attractive for
the sport of diving. Efforts are currently being made by the owners to
secure
funds to enable the provision of proper facilities for diving with
trained
rescue and recovery services on hand. Meanwhile, unauthorised diving in
this
lake, without adequate facilities, has resulted in many accidents and
some
fatalities in almost every year since the quarry closed.
The
North Wales Narrow Gauge Railways – Moel Tryfan Undertaking was a 1ft
11½ ins. gauge line designed and promoted
by Charles Easton Spooner
the Chief Engineer of the Ffestiniog Railway opened in 1877
from Dinas
(south of Caernarfon) to Tryfan Junction and Bryngwyn.[10]
At Bryngwyn, a gravity worked incline ascended at a gradient of 1 in 10
was
owned and operated by the railway company. Radiating out from the
drumhead were
branch lines in the ownership of the various quarries that had linked
their
internal systems to the railway. These branches eventually served Alexandra, Moel Tryfan, Braich, Fron, and
Cilgwyn quarries. Thus, from 1923, Cilgwyn was linked to both the
Nantlle 3ft
6ins gauge tramway (then owned by the LMS) and to the Welsh Highland
Railway
(formerly NWNGR).
When
the Welsh Highland Railway closed in 1936, only Moel Tryfan and Cilgwyn
were
still open.
Yet
a third railway served a few outlying quarries to the south of the main
Nantlle
system, this was the horse drawn 3ft gauge Gorseddau Tramway, which
started
before 1845 as the Tremadoc Tramway between the township and Portmadoc
Harbour.
This line was extended in 1856 to serve the Gorseddau slate quarry – 8
miles
north of Portmadoc. In 1872, this line was reconstructed to 1ft 11½ ins. gauge and incorporated as the Gorseddau
Junction and
Portmadoc Railways Company serving Ynysypandy, Braich, Gorseddau,
Dol-Ifan-Gyfyng, the Cwm Dwyfor Mine and the Prince of Wales
Quarry.
Unfortunately, the poor quality of the slate at these quarries led to
their
early demise. They have left behind evidence of the grand scale in
which they
were planned. Firstly, at Ynysypandy is the ruin of a massive
three-storey mill
incorporating a large water wheel and intended for the manufacture of
slate
slab products from Gorseddau and from the lack of waste it is clear
that the
mill was little used. Secondly at Treforys in Cwmystradllyn are the
ruins of
eighteen pairs of rather grand suburban semis laid out along three
roads
complete with marked out garden plots. All clearly shown on aerial
photographs.[11]
The
Ffestiniog ‘grey’ volcanic mudstone slate mined deep inside the
mountains in
the Ffestiniog area is the odd one out. It is a relatively soft
Ordovician
slate, easy to work and to carve and can even be turned successfully on
a
lathe.[12] It possesses excellent cleavage and produces
some of the thinnest high quality roofing slates in the world. After the early 19th century fire
of
From
1684 or earlier, in the Ffestiniog area, men called slaters had
undertaken building
and repair work using slate that they had extracted from the hillsides
on
common land. However, the first recorded organised slate quarrying at
Ffestiniog appears to have been (c1755-65) by Methusalem Jones, a
quarryman
from Cilgwyn, Nantlle, who was aware of the vast slate deposits that
existed at
Ffestiniog. He opened a small open quarry at Diphwys/Duffws
on Lord Newborough’s Peniarth estate and this
quarry was subsequently worked by partnerships of men mainly from
Cilgwyn. Many
more quarrymen moved from Cilgwyn to Ffestiniog during the second half
of the
eighteenth century[14]. The Diphwys quarry was
sold in 1799 for £14,000 to William Turner
(from the English Lake District) who was financed by the Casson
brothers.
Later, c1790, Lord Newborough opened
Bowydd (later Votty & Bowydd)
quarry to the west-southwest of Diphwys.
These were the first significant workings of Ffestiniog Slate. Other
names
would quickly follow as the landowners began to cash in on the roofing
material
beneath their feet. In 1810, landowner
Evan Owen with 17 men began production at Rhiwbach quarry
four miles east of Diphwys and high in the
mountains at about 1,300 feet. It is in
Penmachno parish and had already been worked spasmodically by slaters,
including those who had re-roofed Ysbyty Ifan church in 1774[15].
The
quarry at Rhiwbryfdir Farm, on the Dinas estate owned by W.G. Oakeley
of Plas
Tanybwlch and first worked around 1814, was leased to Samuel Holland,
who was
to become one of the promoters of the Ffestiniog Railway.
By
1830, the slates from the three main Ffestiniog quarries (Diphwys,
Bowydd and
Rhiwbryfdir) were being carried for two miles in panniers on the backs
of
ponies or mules to Congl y Wal (mid-way between Duffws and Ffestiniog
village)
and then on carts hired out by local farmers, through Ffestiniog and
down 700
feet over rough and muddy roads to small quays on the Traeth Bach along
the
shores of the of the Afon Dwyryd below Maentwrog. Small boats, each
carrying 6
tons, and operated by boatmen known locally as Philistines and who came
from Llanfiangel
y Traethau or Llandecwyn, took the slates to the exposed anchorage of
Ynyscyngar for a third trans-shipment to sea going vessels bound for
Liverpool.
Cost of transporting one ton of slate to this stage was 15s 6d, it
having cost
around £1 to quarry and dress.[16]
Ffestiniog quarries were therefore at a serious disadvantage with the
other
major slate producing areas of
First
proposed in 1824[17]
by Wm
Madocks who died in 1828, then by several others, the Festiniog Railway
Company
was promoted by Samuel and Wm. Holland, and Henry Archer. Archer raised
the
original capital in
Despite
the obvious advantages, the Ffestiniog slate producers were strangely
reluctant
to use the railway. Notwithstanding incentives such as grants to meet
the costs
of connection (building inclines) and the provision by the company of
free
slate wagons for the journey to Portmadoc, and even though the charge
was 6/-
per ton compared with over 15/- per ton by packhorse, road and river,
some
quarries were not connected to the railway until 1843 (seven years
after it had
opened) by which time the railway charges had dropped to 4/3d per ton
and slate
production had risen quickly to 44,000 tons per annum. By 1862, the
population
of Portmadoc had risen to 3,059 and slate
traffic on railway had grown to
54,343 tons.
About 1845, John Greave